Red-brown brick bay-front facade with dark sash windows, a navy entry door, worn granite stoop, and one potted oakleaf hydrangea.

Bay Village Boston Condos: What Park Square’s Office Conversion Means

October 15, 2026

"The location speaks for itself as one of Boston's most desirable neighborhoods," Gila Cohen, managing partner of Vanbarton Group, said in a statement quoted by the Boston Globe in August. She was talking about the Park Square Building at 31 St. James Avenue. It's an 11-story, 540,000-square-foot office block that runs the full length between Arlington and Berkeley streets, a short walk north of Bay Village's federal-style streets. Vanbarton wants to turn it into up to 490 apartments. At an estimated cost of up to $410 million, it would be Boston's largest office-to-residential conversion by a wide margin.

If you're comparing condos in Bay Village with the South End and Back Bay, the headline reads as new supply. The supply is real. It just arrives in a form that leaves the for-sale condo market where it was, and it puts a very specific rent figure next door. To see why, start with what the building sold for.

What $96 million bought in April

The Park Square Building opened in 1923. The Globe says it was once New England's largest building. Its recent price history shows how much value older Back Bay office space has lost:

  • 2017: New York's Capital Properties Management took out a $160 million mortgage on the building.
  • Four fiscal years before 2026: The city's assessed value started a slide that ended 33 percent lower.
  • April 2026: The building sold at foreclosure for $96 million to LNR Partners, a Miami-based subsidiary of Starwood Property Trust. That's about what the building's mortgage was two decades ago, and 19 percent below its already reduced assessment. Universal Hub named the buyer as Starwood Capital Group, but both outlets place the building with a Starwood-affiliated owner.

Universal Hub reported that Capital Properties had "bet big and ultimately lost" on leases to tenants that included WeWork and Yahoo. At $96 million for 540,000 square feet, the building traded at roughly $178 per square foot. That low price is what makes a conversion worth attempting.

Office space at that price can work as housing on paper. It still needs a second input before it works in practice.

Why a distressed office block is where new housing shows up

New residential construction in Boston has slowed sharply. The Globe reported that only two Boston projects of 100 or more units started construction in 2025. The city permitted 1,643 homes in the first half of 2026, after 2023 and 2024 each came in under 2,400 permits, the slowest years since 2011. On September 14, 2026, Mayor Wu proposed about $31.5 million in temporary tax abatements to push four already-approved projects toward construction. The goal is to move at least 1,400 units toward groundbreaking by 2027, and the BPDA board is expected to take up the proposal in October.

So even with approvals in hand, ground-up projects need public money to start. The Park Square Building has a different subsidy available. Universal Hub reported that Vanbarton plans to apply for 29 years of tax breaks under the city's office-to-residential program. The program offers an average abatement of up to 75 percent of assessed residential value for up to 29 years. Applications close December 31, 2026, and projects must pull a full building permit and start construction by December 31, 2027.

The new housing near Bay Village comes from that combination: a building bought at a foreclosure discount, plus a long property-tax abatement. Even with both, the project is expensive. Up to $410 million across 490 units works out to about $840,000 per apartment. For comparison, the median condo sale price across the Greater Boston Association of Realtors' coverage area was $725,000 in August 2026. The location isn't the same, but the gap shows how much it costs to create a new home near Park Square, even starting from a discounted shell.

What the apartments are designed to be

A building that costs that much per unit has to collect rent to match. The Globe reported proposed market rents of $6.50 to $7.50 per square foot. That's roughly $5,425 a month for a 775-square-foot apartment, and it applies to the 80 percent of the building not set aside at affordable rents.

The two public reports describe the unit count a little differently, depending on the filing:

Item What's been reported
Total apartments Up to 490 in the conversion application (Globe, August 2026); 476 in the letter of intent (Universal Hub, September 2026)
Unit sizes Studios through two-bedrooms, plus a few three-bedrooms
Income-restricted units 81, for households earning up to 60% of area median income
Voucher-eligible units 14 at market rents, open to tenants with Section 8 or similar vouchers
Retail About 30,000 sq. ft. of ground-floor space kept
Rooftop A proposed 9,000 sq. ft. "penthouse" roof deck

The current ground-floor tenants include Roche Bobois and the restaurant Fire + Ice. The building also houses the French, Colombian, Portuguese and Turkish consulates. In its application, Vanbarton said the nearly two dozen office tenants are expected to move out within a year.

Vanbarton has done this before. It completed a 588-unit conversion at 160 Water Street in New York and has another 1,511 units under construction in three other New York buildings. This would be its first development in Boston.

What it changes for someone buying a Bay Village condo

Every unit in the proposal is a rental. Owner-occupied inventory in Bay Village, Back Bay and the South End stays the same size, whatever happens at 31 St. James. A buyer looking at a Bay Village flat in 2026 or 2027 is choosing from the same small pool of existing condos as before.

What does change is the comparison buyers and sellers will make next door. A proposed rent of about $5,425 for 775 square feet becomes a public reference point a few blocks from Bay Village. When a buyer adds up mortgage, taxes and condo fees on a comparable flat, the figure on the other side is now new-build, amenitized rental space with a roof deck. For sellers, that number shapes how buyers see the cost of renting versus owning. If you're working through ownership costs in older buildings, our guide to Back Bay condo fees covers how monthly charges are built.

Timing matters too. The project needs approval, has to finish relocating its office tenants, and must start construction by the end of 2027 to keep its program eligibility. A buyer closing in the next year should expect this block to be in planning or under construction for a good part of their early ownership. Citywide, the Globe reported in August that fewer than 20 percent of the 2,331 units proposed for office conversion had been built or were under construction. By June 2026, the Planning Department counted 26 program applicants on track to convert 31 buildings into 1,785 homes. That's a pipeline figure, not occupied apartments.

The dates on the public record

The Boston Planning Department tracks the project as 140 Providence Street. Here's its timeline so far:

  1. August 28, 2026: Letter of Intent filed.
  2. September 25, 2026: Project Notification Form filed and the comment period opened.
  3. October 14, 2026, 6 to 8 p.m.: Virtual public meeting.
  4. October 26, 2026: Comment period closes.
  5. December 31, 2026: Deadline to apply to the city's conversion program.
  6. December 31, 2027: Deadline for a full building permit and construction start under the program.

The project is in the Letter of Intent and Under Review stages. Unit counts, the rooftop plan and the schedule can all change before the board votes.

FAQ

Is the Park Square Building inside Bay Village?

No. It fills the St. James Avenue block from Arlington to Berkeley, which the Globe describes as Back Bay. Bay Village is a short walk south. Our Bay Village guide covers the neighborhood's own streets.

Will any of the units be sold as condos?

Everything reported so far describes rental apartments. The filings and coverage don't mention any for-sale units.

Can neighbors weigh in?

Yes. The city's project page takes comments through October 26, 2026, and the virtual meeting is October 14.

Does the ground-floor retail stay?

Vanbarton has said it plans to keep about 30,000 square feet of ground-floor retail, with resident amenities on the same level.

If you own a Bay Village condo and want to know how a 490-unit rental project next door could affect your sale price and timing, The Residential Group prices condos against the newest comparisons nearby, including this one. List With Confidence.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Let’s Talk Real Estate

The Residential Group at William Raveis Real Estate is a team of experienced agents, specializing in the sale of urban dwellings and new construction/renovation properties in Metropolitan Boston. They are consistently ranked among the top sales teams at William Raveis Real Estate and top teams in all of Massachusetts.